Tryout & Player Evaluation Forms

Free printable evaluation forms for baseball and softball tryouts

Run organized tryouts with structured evaluation forms. Rate players on hitting, fielding, baserunning, pitching, and intangibles using a consistent 1-5 scale. Each form includes a scoring rubric so every evaluator grades the same way. Two forms print per page.

Looking for more coaching printables?

Pitch trackers, tryout forms, skills assessments, practice plans and more.

Browse All Printables→

Tryouts & Evaluations

Player evaluation forms for tryouts and pre-season assessments.

Baseball Player Evaluations

Preview of Youth Baseball Player Evaluation printable PDF template

Youth Baseball Player Evaluation

Tryout evaluation form for ages 8-12. Skill ratings for hitting, fielding, baserunning, and pitching. Includes scoring rubric.

Download
Preview of High School Baseball Evaluation printable PDF template
Premium

High School Baseball Evaluation

Premium

Advanced evaluation form for ages 14-18. Detailed skill ratings including velocity, command, plate discipline. Includes scoring rubric.

Unlock with Premium

Softball Player Evaluations

Preview of Youth Softball Player Evaluation printable PDF template

Youth Softball Player Evaluation

Tryout evaluation form for ages 8-12. Softball-specific skills including bunting and windmill pitching. Includes scoring rubric.

Download
Preview of High School Softball Evaluation printable PDF template
Premium

High School Softball Evaluation

Premium

Advanced evaluation form for ages 14-18. Softball-specific skills including slap hitting and windmill mechanics. Includes scoring rubric.

Unlock with Premium

Frequently Asked Questions

What should a baseball tryout evaluation form include?
A good evaluation form includes player info fields, skill ratings on a 1-5 scale for hitting, fielding, baserunning, pitching, and intangibles like attitude and coachability. Our forms include a scoring rubric so all evaluators rate consistently.
What is the difference between the youth and high school evaluation forms?
The youth form (ages 8-12) focuses on fundamental skills: throwing mechanics, catching consistency, bat contact, and baserunning awareness. The high school form (ages 14-18) adds advanced metrics like velocity, command, plate discipline, and game IQ.
How many evaluators should use the form at tryouts?
At least two independent evaluators per station. This reduces bias and gives a more complete picture. After tryouts, compare scores and discuss players where evaluators diverged significantly.
Can I use these forms for mid-season evaluations?
Yes. The same form works for tryouts, pre-season assessments, and mid-season check-ins. Comparing scores across time points shows player development and helps identify areas that need focused coaching.

Related Coaching Resources

How to Keep Score in Baseball

Step-by-step guide to scorekeeping notation, symbols, and recording plays.

Lineup Card Templates

16 free printable lineup cards — the companion to your scorecard.

Virtual Scoreboard

Free game-day scoreboard that shows the score to both benches live.

Pitch Count Tracker

Track pitch counts and rest days by Little League and USSSA rules.

Free Lineup Generator

Auto-build batting orders and defensive rotations in seconds.

Free Practice Planner

Build organized practice plans with drills, stations, and time blocks.

Coming 2026

Skip the paper next season. Score your games digitally.

Our digital baseball scorebook drops every at-bat into a scorecard for you, rolls up season stats automatically, and rebuilds lineups based on who is actually hot. Launching in 2026. Join the waitlist and we will send early access the week it goes live.

Want to see it in context? Read what the digital scorekeeper does.